Azure Key Vault vs. AWS Secrets Manager 

Back to: ASP.NET Core Identity Tutorials

Azure Key Vault vs. AWS Secrets Manager 

In this article, I will discuss Azure Key Vault vs. AWS Secrets Manager. Please read our previous article discussing ASP.NET Core Secret Manager.

Azure Key Vault vs. AWS Secrets Manager

Azure Key Vault and AWS Secrets Manager are cloud-based services that Microsoft Azure and Amazon Web Services (AWS) provide. They are designed to securely store and manage sensitive information such as keys, secrets, and certificates. These services are crucial in managing the security aspect of application development and maintenance, especially in cloud environments.

What is Azure Key Vault?

Azure Key Vault is a cloud service provided by Microsoft Azure that offers secure storage of secrets, keys, and certificates. It’s designed to safeguard cryptographic keys and other secrets used in cloud applications and services. Here are the key features and uses of Azure Key Vault:

Secure Secret Storage

• Secrets Management: Azure Key Vault can securely store and tightly control access to tokens, passwords, certificates, API keys, and other secrets.
• Encryption Keys Management: You can use Key Vault to create and control the encryption keys to encrypt your data.
• Certificate Management: It also allows for managing SSL/TLS certificates used by Azure services and applications.

Key Features

• Centralized Management: Provides a central place to manage all your application secrets.
• Access Control: Fine-grained control over who and what can access your keys, secrets, and certificates.
• Secure Key Management: Azure Key Vault uses Hardware Security Modules (HSMs) to protect and manage your keys. You can import or generate keys in HSMs.
• Auditing: Offers monitoring and logging capabilities to track how and when your secrets are accessed.

Integration with Other Azure Services

• Azure Active Directory (AAD) Integration: Key Vault integrates with AAD for identity management and access control.
• Developer Friendly: It can be integrated with various Azure services and applications. For example, it can be used to store database connection strings for Azure Web Apps.
• Automation and DevOps Support: Key Vault supports automation tools and DevOps scenarios, allowing you to incorporate secret management into your automated workflows.

Use Cases

• Protecting Application Secrets: Storing API keys, database connection strings, or other application-specific secrets.
• Certificate Management: Automating the process of managing SSL/TLS certificates for your applications.
• Data Encryption: Storing encryption keys for encrypting sensitive data in your applications.

Compliance and Standards

• Azure Key Vault is designed to meet various compliance standards, which is crucial for enterprises concerned with regulatory requirements.

How to Use Azure Key Vault?

To use Azure Key Vault, you need an Azure subscription. You can create a Key Vault using the Azure portal, Azure CLI, or Azure PowerShell. Once created, you can add secrets, keys, or certificates and manage permissions to access your applications or services.

What is AWS Secrets Manager?

AWS Secrets Manager is a service provided by Amazon Web Services (AWS) that helps you protect access to your applications, services, and IT resources without the upfront cost and complexity of maintaining your own infrastructure for secret management. This service primarily stores and manages sensitive information such as database credentials, API keys, and other secrets. Here are some of its key features and benefits:

1. Secure and Manage Secrets: It allows you to easily rotate, manage, and retrieve database credentials, API keys, and other secrets throughout their lifecycle.
2. Secret Rotation: AWS Secrets Manager can automatically rotate the secrets as needed. You can set a rotation schedule, and the service handles the rotation process.
3. Centralized Management: It provides a central place to manage secrets, simplifying the task of managing credentials and secrets across various applications and services.
4. Integration with AWS Services: It integrates seamlessly with other AWS services, enabling you to retrieve secrets within AWS Lambda functions, Amazon RDS instances, Amazon Redshift, and more.
5. Fine-Grained Access Control: You can control access to secrets using AWS Identity and Access Management (IAM) policies, ensuring that only authorized users and applications can retrieve them.
6. Encryption: Secrets are encrypted using encryption keys you create and control through AWS Key Management Service (KMS).
7. Auditing and Monitoring: Integration with AWS CloudTrail provides a way to audit access and changes to secrets, enhancing security and compliance.
8. Cross-Account Access: You can manage secrets across different AWS accounts, simplifying secret management in complex environments.

Use Cases

• Database Credential Storage: Storing credentials for accessing databases securely and providing them to applications as needed.
• API Key Management: Storing and managing API keys for various services and applications.
• Application Configuration: Storing application configuration details, like feature flags or service endpoints.

Benefits

• Improved Security: By centralizing the management of secrets and enabling automatic rotation, AWS Secrets Manager enhances the security of applications.
• Reduced Complexity: It simplifies the management of secrets, especially in large or complex environments.
• Compliance: Helps meet compliance requirements by providing secure storage and management of secrets.

Key Differences Between Azure Key Vault and AWS Secrets Manager

• Secrets Rotation: AWS Secrets Manager emphasizes the automatic rotation of secrets, which can be a significant advantage in managing credentials that need regular updates.
• Pricing Model: Azure Key Vault’s pricing focuses more on the type of keys and number of operations, while AWS Secrets Manager emphasizes the number of rotations and API calls.
• Ecosystem Integration: Each service is optimized for its respective cloud environment, providing better integration and functionality within their ecosystems.

Choosing Between Azure Key Vault and AWS Secrets Manager

• Existing Cloud Infrastructure: If you’re already using services within a specific cloud provider, using the corresponding secrets management service might be more convenient and cost-effective.
• Specific Features: Evaluate features like secret rotation, pricing, and integration capabilities according to your project needs.
• Compliance and Security Requirements: Consider your organization’s compliance standards and security requirements.

In the next article, I will discuss Configuring Email Service in ASP.NET Core Identity. In this article, I explain Azure Key Vault vs. AWS Secrets Manager. I hope you enjoy this article, Azure Key Vault vs. AWS Secrets Manager.